When people rank dogs by intelligence, they usually mean how quickly a dog learns to obey. The best-known ranking, from Stanley Coren's book The Intelligence of Dogs, was built on the opinions of obedience trial judges, and it measures exactly that: how few repetitions a breed needs to learn a command and how reliably it complies the first time.
That is one kind of clever. Solving problems alone, reading people's moods, remembering where things are and following a scent for miles are others. A herding dog bred to take direction from a shepherd will always look brighter on an obedience test than a hound bred to work a quarter mile ahead of the hunter, making its own decisions.
These seventeen breeds have more going on upstairs than they get credit for. Some score high on the standard lists and are simply overlooked. Others score near the bottom and are among the best independent problem solvers in the dog world.
A bright dog with nothing to think about becomes a barker, a digger or an escape artist. For every breed here, the tip is a practical way to give that brain a job.
Read all the way to the end. The last breed is famous for being stubborn, and that is the proof.
-
Tiny genius
1. Papillon
Photo: Anna King / Unsplash Is yours on the list?The little dog with butterfly ears is the highest-ranked toy breed on Coren's list, in eighth place overall, ahead of many famous working dogs. Papillons learn a new command in a handful of repetitions and remember it.
They regularly beat much bigger breeds in obedience and dominate the small-dog classes in agility, where speed has to be matched by split-second attention to the handler. A Papillon weighs five to ten pounds and behaves like a small, quick spaniel, which is what its ancestors were.
AdvertisementThe risk is treating one like an ornament. An untrained Papillon becomes yappy and bossy out of sheer boredom.
Put it to workTeach a new trick every week. They get bored without a challenge, and five minutes twice a day is enough. -
Nose detective
2. Bloodhound
Photo: gary smith / Unsplash Is yours on the list?A Bloodhound has around 300 million scent receptors, more than any other breed, and the long ears and loose facial skin help sweep odor toward the nose. It can follow a trail that is days old over miles of ground, and its trailing results have been accepted as evidence in American courts.
AdvertisementThis is highly specialized intelligence. The dog is sorting one person's scent from thousands of others and holding it in memory for hours. It seems stubborn only because its nose has the final say, and a call from you cannot compete with a fresh trail.
At 80 to 110 pounds, a Bloodhound on a scent pulls hard. A secure fence and a leash are not optional.
AdvertisementPut it to workHide treats around the yard and let the nose do the work. Graduate to having a family member hide and letting the dog find them. -
Hunter's mind
3. Beagle
Photo: Milli / Unsplash Is yours on the list?Beagles were bred to run in packs and think for themselves while tracking rabbits and hares, well out of reach of any handler. They sit near the bottom of obedience rankings for the same reason they excel at their real work: they follow evidence, not orders.
At home that intelligence is pointed at food. Beagles are expert at working out where it is kept, which cupboard door does not latch, and which chair gets them to the counter. Their sense of smell is good enough that they are used to screen luggage at American airports for prohibited food.
AdvertisementThey gain weight easily, so the food drive needs managing.
A dog that ignores you is not always a slow one.
Put it to workUse puzzle feeders or a snuffle mat instead of a bowl. Making a Beagle hunt for dinner uses its brain and slows its eating. -
Barn manager
4. Rat Terrier
Photo: Victor G / Unsplash Is yours on the list?The Rat Terrier is an American farm dog, bred to keep barns and granaries free of vermin and to do whatever else needed doing. It is quick, watchful and unusually eager to please for a terrier.
AdvertisementThat mix makes it one of the easiest terriers to train. Rat Terriers learn house rules fast, notice everything, and pick up on patterns such as which shoes mean a walk. They do well in agility, barn hunt and trick classes.
They have less of the argumentative streak found in some terriers, but they keep the prey drive. Pet rodents and a Rat Terrier do not mix.
Put it to workShort, lively training games suit this breed best. Three five-minute sessions beat one long one. -
Little captain
5. Schipperke
Is yours on the list?This small black Belgian dog earned its keep as a watchdog and ratter on canal barges and in workshops. The name is usually translated as little captain. It weighs only 10 to 16 pounds and is curious to a fault.
AdvertisementA Schipperke investigates everything and remembers how every latch and gate works. Owners describe dogs that open crates, nudge sliding doors and find the one loose board in a fence. It is observation and memory, put to mischievous use.
They are alert barkers and independent thinkers, so training has to be interesting enough to win their cooperation.
Put it to workKeep gates secure, and give it a job such as finding hidden toys by name.Advertisement -
Problem solver
6. Standard Schnauzer
Photo: stephan de MARANTHI / Unsplash Is yours on the list?The Standard is the original Schnauzer, from which the Miniature and Giant were later developed. On German farms it herded stock, guarded the wagon, killed rats and watched the children, and a dog with that many duties has to be adaptable.
Schnauzers weigh up a situation before acting and remember what worked last time. They learn fast and then begin to improvise, which trainers sometimes mistake for disobedience. Drill a Standard Schnauzer on the same exercise ten times and by the fifth it will be offering a variation.
They are protective and physical, at 30 to 50 pounds, and need an owner with a sense of humor and clear rules.
AdvertisementPut it to workVary the routine. They quickly tire of repeating the same exercise, so change the order, the place and the reward. -
People reader
7. Keeshond
Is yours on the list?The Keeshond is a Dutch barge dog, bred as a companion and watchdog, and its intelligence is social. Keeshonds are highly tuned to human moods. They notice a change in your voice or posture and adjust.
They do very well in obedience work and sit comfortably in the top quarter of Coren's ranking, though few people think of them as a clever breed. The distinctive markings around the eyes, which look like spectacles, give them a thoughtful expression that happens to be accurate.
AdvertisementTheir sensitivity makes them excellent therapy dogs. It also means they dislike being left out, and a lonely Keeshond will bark.
Put it to workThey thrive on praise more than treats. Keep training cheerful and include them in the daily routine. -
Eager student
8. Brittany
Photo: Peggy Paulson / Unsplash Is yours on the list?This compact bird dog has energy to spare and a real wish to get things right. A Brittany hunts close to the gun and checks back with its handler constantly, which makes it more attentive to people than most sporting breeds.
AdvertisementBrittanys pick up hand signals as quickly as spoken words, because in the field they were directed by gesture and whistle. The breed has produced more dual champions, dogs titled in both field trials and the show ring, than any other sporting breed.
They are soft-natured and wilt under harsh handling. They also need a great deal of running, at least an hour of hard exercise a day.
Put it to workTry teaching silent signals for sit, stay and come. A Brittany watches your hands more closely than you realize. -
Cattle boss
9. Australian Cattle Dog
Photo: Marcin Wojna / Unsplash Is yours on the list?Cattle Dogs were bred to move stubborn livestock over huge distances in the Australian outback and to make decisions alone. Dingo blood went into the breed for toughness and stamina. They rank tenth on Coren's list.
AdvertisementWhat sets them apart is foresight. A Cattle Dog watches where animals, people and cars are heading and positions itself ahead of time. Owners find these dogs waiting at the right door before anyone has reached for a leash.
The herding style is to nip at heels, and an underemployed Cattle Dog will try it on joggers, bicycles and grandchildren.
Without work they invent their own, and it is rarely work you would have chosen.
Put it to workGive them a daily task: carrying a pack on walks, herding lessons, or fetching named objects.Advertisement -
Quiet thinker
10. Shetland Sheepdog
Photo: Kat van der Linden / Unsplash Is yours on the list?The Sheltie ranks sixth on Coren's list, which puts it among the handful of breeds that learn a new command in fewer than five repetitions. It is still thought of mainly as a pretty, small Collie.
Shelties understand a large vocabulary and often anticipate what you want before you ask. They learn the household schedule in detail and can become anxious when it changes. In obedience and agility they are consistently among the top-scoring breeds.
They are sensitive to noise and tone and can be shy with strangers. They also bark, a habit inherited from farm work and best addressed early.
AdvertisementPut it to workName their toys. Many Shelties can learn to fetch each one by name, and adding a new word every week keeps them engaged. -
Willing partner
11. English Springer Spaniel
Photo: Nick Russill / Unsplash Is yours on the list?Springers are widely used by police and customs services as detection dogs for explosives, drugs and cash. The job demands a fine nose, the stamina to search for hours, and a dog that works for the pleasure of pleasing its handler.
The breed combines all three. A Springer learns a target scent quickly, searches methodically and gives a clear signal when it finds something. It ranks thirteenth on Coren's list.
AdvertisementField-bred Springers are lighter and more driven than show-bred ones, and both need plenty of exercise. Check the long ears weekly, because they are prone to infection.
Put it to workScent games in the yard will tire a Springer faster than a long walk. Start with a favorite toy hidden in plain sight and make it harder. -
Clown with a brain
12. Miniature Schnauzer
Photo: Sebastian Coman Travel / Unsplash Is yours on the list?Underneath the eyebrows and the beard is a sharp, alert dog that ranks twelfth on Coren's list, higher than most people would guess for a small terrier type.
A Miniature Schnauzer learns routines after one or two repetitions, including the ones you wish it had not. Feed it from the table once and it has a new rule. It is also a keen watchdog that learns the sound of each family member's car.
AdvertisementThe breed is prone to pancreatitis and bladder stones, so fatty table scraps are a bad idea on medical grounds as well as training ones.
Put it to workBe consistent. They spot every loophole, so make sure everyone in the house follows the same rules. -
Family watcher
13. Collie
Photo: Kim Eggler / Unsplash Is yours on the list?The Lassie stories exaggerated, but not by much. Collies are sensitive, observant and quick to notice when something is out of place, whether that is a gate left open or a child in the wrong part of the yard.
AdvertisementThe Scottish shepherds who developed them needed a dog that could gather sheep at a distance and also be gentle around the home. The result is a breed that learns easily and bonds to the whole family, not to one person.
Collies come in rough and smooth coats with the same temperament. They can be vocal, and many carry a gene that makes them dangerously sensitive to certain common drugs. A simple DNA test settles it.
Put it to workThey respond to a quiet voice. Harsh training backfires and makes a Collie hesitant.Advertisement -
Big-dog attitude
14. Pomeranian
Photo: stefanus fandhy / Unsplash Is yours on the list?Poms descend from much larger spitz-type sled and herding dogs and were bred down to their present three to seven pounds in the nineteenth century. They kept the brains and the confidence.
They rank in the top third on obedience lists and excel at tricks. Their alertness makes them effective little watchdogs that announce every arrival.
The weak point is house-training, which takes longer in toy breeds and calls for patience and a strict schedule. Barking also needs early attention.
Put it to workTrick training keeps a Pom busy and quieter. Teach a "quiet" cue alongside the fun ones.Advertisement -
Cat in a dog suit
15. Basenji
Photo: David Clarke / Unsplash Is yours on the list?The African Basenji is one of the oldest breeds, a silent hunter from the Congo basin that does not bark but yodels. It is independent, fastidiously clean and clever at getting what it wants.
It sits second from the bottom of the obedience ranking, and that says more about the test than the dog. A Basenji will not obey to please you, but it will climb a chain-link fence, open a cupboard or solve a puzzle to get dinner.
They hunt by sight and scent, are very fast, and should never be off leash in an unfenced area.
Put it to workMake training worth its while with high-value rewards, and keep sessions to a few minutes.Advertisement -
Independent hound
16. Afghan Hound
Photo: Artem Sapegin / Unsplash Is yours on the list?Afghans come last on Coren's obedience ranking and do not care. They were bred to hunt in the mountains of Afghanistan far ahead of horsemen, chasing down hares and gazelle and deciding for themselves how to do it.
A dog doing that work at 40 miles an hour cannot wait for instructions. The Afghan's aloofness is the mark of a specialist, not a dull mind. At home they are gentle, clownish with people they trust, and good at quietly taking food off counters.
Recall is unreliable once they see something run. The long coat needs several hours of grooming a week.
AdvertisementPut it to workJudge them by what they work out alone, not by how fast they sit. Lure coursing lets an Afghan do what it was made for. -
Determined digger
17. Dachshund
Photo: Katie Bernotsky / Unsplash Is yours on the list?Dachshunds were bred in Germany to go underground after badgers, an animal that fights back, and to make life-or-death decisions on their own in the dark. The name means badger dog.
That is where the famous stubbornness comes from. A Dachshund keeps at a problem long after another breed would give up, whether the problem is a badger, a mole in the lawn or a treat under the sofa. They have excellent noses and are used in Europe to track wounded deer.
AdvertisementThey bark more than their size suggests, and house-training takes persistence.
Put it to workKeep sessions short and end on a success. Scent trails laid across the lawn are ideal work for a Dachshund and easy on its long back.
The short version
A dog that ignores you is not always a slow one. Many of the cleverest breeds were built to think alone, and obedience rankings measure willingness as much as ability. Hounds and terriers that score poorly on them can out-think a retriever when the task is finding, digging or getting into a locked bin.
Find out what your dog was bred to do, then give it a version of that job. Noses need trails to follow. Herders need direction and tasks. Small companion breeds need tricks and conversation. Ten minutes of mental work a day does as much for a dog's behavior as a long walk.
Do that and you will see how bright your dog really is. You will also have a calmer one, because most of what people call bad behavior in a smart dog is a good mind with nothing to do.
Last updated .
